Whonix ™ Forums Usage Instructions, Best Practices and FAQ
Creating an Anonymous Email Account for Support
Users can try Danwin1210.me [archive], CTemplar [archive] , Anonymous Speech [archive] or ProtonMail [archive]. These links are not an endorsement! Users should not trust the providers with any of their personal information, but only use them for creating the forum account.
As a last resort, Patrick in chat with the desired user name and password. An account can then be created which does not require e-mail verification.
Posting Links for New Users
To prevent spam, posting hyperlinks in Whonix ™ forums disabled for new users. Instead please use code tags for links such as. Instead of just writing the link, surround it by prepending and appending an apostrophe ("
Or make a new line for a link and add 4 white spaces in front of it. Example:
New users accounts that did not spam will be permitted to post links.
Uploading Images for Support
Uploading images to Whonix ™ forums is unsupported. Consider using a free image upload service instead. For example, users could try anonfiles.com (clearnet) [archive] (onion [archive]). Then copy the links to the uploaded images to your forum post.
Pasting Logs for Support
Pasting logs, even lengthy ones, to Whonix ™ forums is OK.
If the forum software doesn't allow it if the log is too long, split the log into multiple posts if reasonable or consider using a free pastebin service instead. For example, users could try anonpaste.org (clearnet) [archive]. Then copy the link to the pasted log to your forum post.
Avoid Oneboxing for Anchored Links
When a direct, non-anchored link is posted, for example
https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Tor_Controller [archive], no special consideration is required. Oneboxing is used automatically, unless a forum poster wishes to avoid it for some reason. 
Oneboxing should be avoided if posting an anchored link, such as
https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Tor_Controller#Arm [archive]. To achieve this, add a space
Before Creating a New Thread
Similar to the Reporting Guidelines for bugs, users are recommended to search the Documentation, existing forum topics, and other Internet resources for their issue/area of interest prior to creating a new topic thread. This is considered good forum behavior.
In many cases the issue has already been documented, identified or discussed before, often with a settled answer or solution. The easiest way to search the forums is to use the search link near the top of the page. Forum posts are also indexed by search engines, so combining "Whonix" with the relevant query might also find pertinent entries:
site:forums.whonix.org What I want to know
At their discretion, Whonix ™ forum moderators may combine (or split) threads if they are closely (distantly) related. This helps interested readers to remain focused on a solitary issue, thereby improving the productivity of conversations.
Bumping Old Threads
Related to the issue above, it is suggested to 'resuscitate' (bump) old threads on an existing topic. This way all related talking points are in the same location -- reducing the amount of duplicated information and search-related noise in the process.
One exception to this recommendation may be threads that are already several years old. If the situation has significantly changed, it may be appropriate to start a new thread; for example, if software or protocol changes make older information irrelevant.
Clean Mediawiki Links
Please do not posts links such as
https://www.whonix.org/w/index.php?title=Dev/mediawiki&stable=0s [archive]. This happens when a forum user shares a link to a page that was edited. These links are undesirable because it is interpreted as a bug (or strange feature) by mediawiki.  Instead, post 'clean' links like
https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Dev/mediawiki [archive]. To switch from the 'bad' link to the 'good' link, click the "Page" button on the top left of the screen twice.
A less well known, but useful forum feature concerns embedded quotes. When clicking on a quote posted in the forum, it will expand and show more context.
Editing Best Practices
Some forum posters seek to improve the quality of the forums and their posts by editing earlier entries with additional information. This is unrecommended because there is no notification feature built into the software to announce edits, meaning those who already read your post will be unaware of the changes.
Two better options exist:
- Edit the old post and then make a new post confirming the change, with an additional request the notification be deleted after a short period. Later, either delete the notification post or wait for the forum moderators to do so.
- Create a new post in the existing thread instead. So long as the reply is constructive, this approach is fine.
It is not useful to edit old posts for minor issues, such as typos or grammatical errors.
Common questions raised in the Whonix ™ forums are answered below.
Why was my post moved by a moderator?
In this case, the post probably touched on a subject that was not related to the current topic. To avoid confusion and to keep the forums productive, the post was either moved to an existing thread or used to create a new topic discussion.
Where did my post/thread disappear to?
- It was moved to a different sub-topic.
- Multiple users flagged the post/thread. When that happens, the post is automatically hidden from view until until a moderator has reviewed the post.
- It was removed for legal reasons, see: Limitations on Free Speech on Whonix ™ Website
- To clarify the thread/topic, the title may have been changed. When this occurs the thread cannot be located with the former title.
Why was my forum thread closed?
Similar to the answers above, the thread may have:
- Contained off-topic discussions unrelated to Whonix ™ and technical matters.
- Replicated existing posts/threads.
- Otherwise run afoul of the forum policies.
In the event the content was similar to existing posts/threads, the latest post(s) will normally be moved to the existing thread before closure.
TODO: Expand this section.
Forum Feature Requests
Most requests for improvements to the forum software or functionality cannot be actioned by the Whonix ™ project. For further details, see: Privacy on the Whonix ™ Website.
- Please use Search Engines and see Documentation First
- Free Support Principle
- Policy of Whonix Website and Whonix Chat
- Wiki Comments Policy
- Limitations on Free Speech on Whonix Website and Whonix Chat
- https://forums.whonix.org/t/which-e-mail-provider-is-more-adviseable-protonmail-or-lavabit-reloaded/3459/45 [archive]
- For example, when posting a large number of links in succession. This can take up unnecessary space in the post depending on the number of references.
- TODO: figure out if there is an upstream bug report at the mediawiki bug tracker.
This is a wiki. Want to improve this page? Help is welcome and volunteer contributions are happily considered! Read, understand and agree to Conditions for Contributions to Whonix ™, then Edit! Edits are held for moderation. Policy of Whonix Website and Whonix Chat and Policy On Nonfreedom Software applies.
Copyright (C) 2012 - 2020 ENCRYPTED SUPPORT LP. Whonix ™ is a trademark. Whonix ™ is a licensee [archive] of the Open Invention Network [archive]. Unless otherwise noted, the content of this page is copyrighted and licensed under the same Freedom Software license as Whonix ™ itself. (Why?)