Chaining Anonymizing Gateways

From Whonix

Chaininganon23234.jpg

Introduction[edit]

Info Only advanced users should attempt these configurations!

By default, all Whonix-Workstation ™ traffic is forced through Whonix-Gateway ™. Alternatively, a chain of anonymizing gateways can be built, with sample tunnel configurations outlined below.

Before attempting complex tunnel configurations, the following basic knowledge is required:

This Inspiration resource may also be useful.

Possible Configurations[edit]

Pre-Tor-VPN[edit]

## chain: Whonix-Workstation ™ -> VPN-Gateway -> Whonix-Gateway ™ -> clearnet ## connection scheme: user -> VPN -> Tor -> Internet

For instructions, see here. To learn more details about this configuration, refer to this entry.

Post-Tor-VPN[edit]

## chain: Whonix-Workstation ™ -> Whonix-Gateway ™ -> VPN-Gateway -> clearnet ## connection scheme: user -> Tor -> VPN -> Internet

For instructions, see here. To learn more details about this configuration, refer to this entry.

Pre- and Post-Tor-VPN[edit]

## chain: Whonix-Workstation ™ -> VPN-Gateway -> Whonix-Gateway ™ -> VPN-Gateway -> Internet ## connection scheme: user -> VPN -> Tor -> VPN -> Internet

Whonix ™ is not limited to VPN-Gateways; the VPN can be replaced with a Proxy-Gateway.

Post-Tor-Proxy[edit]

## chain: Whonix-Workstation ™ -> Proxy-Gateway -> Whonix-Gateway ™ -> clearnet ## connection scheme: user -> Tor -> Proxy -> Internet

For instructions, see here. To learn more details about this configuration, refer to this entry.

Other Connection Schemes[edit]

Virtually any combination is possible: a Post-Tor-Proxy; a Pre/Post-Tor-SSH; or the proxy being replaced with JonDo or perhaps I2P.

Always remember that the connection will be created in reverse order; see the example below. [1]

## chain: Whonix-Workstation ™ -> Proxy-Gateway -> Whonix-Gateway ™ -> VPN-Gateway -> clearnet ## connection scheme: user -> VPN -> Tor -> Proxy -> Internet

Upon reflection, it becomes clear why the connection happens in reverse order:

  • Whonix-Workstation ™ has no option but to pass through the Proxy-Gateway.
  • The Proxy-Gateway has no option but to pass through Whonix-Gateway ™.
  • In this case, the last element in the chain is the VPN-Gateway, which must obviously connect via clearnet.

In other terms:

  • The VPN-Gateway uses clearnet.
  • Whonix-Gateway ™ uses the VPN-Gateway to connect.
  • The Proxy-Gateway uses Whonix-Gateway ™ to connect.
  • Whonix-Workstation ™ uses the Proxy-Gateway to connect.

Since the Proxy-Gateway can only pass through Whonix-Gateway ™ followed by the VPN-Gateway, it is clear why it will be the last hop in front of the destination server.

Other Considerations[edit]

Whether these combinations make sense in terms of security and anonymity is hotly debated and depends on your personal threat model, see Tor plus VPN or Proxy. Advanced tunneling configurations also require knowledge of how to properly edit /etc/network/interfaces on Whonix-Gateway ™ and/or on Whonix-Workstation ™. In the case of Non-Qubes-Whonix ™, this refers to the virtual internal network name in VirtualBox settings.

This process is generally difficult because there are no other anonymizing gateways (VPN / JonDo / I2P / Proxy / SSH / VPN) available for download in Whonix ™, just the Whonix-Gateway ™ which uses Tor to anonymize traffic. This means a search for instructions is often required and/or an anonymizing gateway must be built from scratch. [2]

For a VPN-Gateway, see also:

Footnotes[edit]

  1. "Internet" below refers to the destination server, such as a website.
  2. Instructions for a pfSense based VPN-Gateway can be found with search engines, but it is untested for leaks.