Dev/64bit
Contents
Basics[edit]
During Whonix's build process, first a Debian raw image is created using grml-debootstrap. A raw image and not qcow2, vdi or vmdk, because creating a bootable raw image is difficult and there are no tools yet to create a qcow2, vdi or vmdk image from scratch.
When (also) using the --target virtualbox switch, the raw image gets converted to vdi. Then a VirtualBox virtual machine is created, the vdi added to it and exported. During export, VirtualBox unfortunately converts it to vmdk.
When (also) using the --target qcow2 switch, the raw image gets converted to qcow2.
Maintenance effort definition: Images need to be build, tested, signed, uploaded, maintained (updates), supported (triage bugs, answer questions).
32 bit vs 64 bit[edit]
64 bit builds can not be run on 32 bit computers, can not be run on computers without pae.
64 bit libvirt builds could probably not run in QEMU on 32 bit computers but QEMU support is deprecated since there is no Whonix maintainer. See QEMU.
Current Situation[edit]
Qubes-Whonix official builds are 64 bit only.
Non-Qubes-Whonix official builds are 32 bit only. Maintenance effort currently includes 6 images. Although build time, upload time and maintenance effort for Whonix-Custom-Workstation does not add up so much, because there is probably rarely need to update it (only when VM settings would change).
- Whonix-Gateway 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Workstation 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Custom-Workstation ova
- Whonix-Gateway 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Workstation 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Custom-Workstation libvirt
With additional 64 bit builds[edit]
If Whonix offered additional official 64 bit builds next to 32 bit builds, maintenance effort would multiply two times.
Maintenance effort would include 10 images.
- Whonix-Gateway 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Gateway 64 bit ova
- Whonix-Workstation 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Workstation 64 bit ova
- Whonix-Custom-Workstation ova
- Whonix-Gateway 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Gateway 64 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Workstation 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Workstation 64 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Custom-Workstation libvirt
non-Debian builds[edit]
Unrealistic in near future. Just for a fun thought experiment, imagine Whonix offered official non-Debian, let's say for example Fedora based images.
- Whonix-Debian-Gateway 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Debian-Gateway 64 bit ova
- Whonix-Debian-Workstation 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Debian-Workstation 64 bit ova
- Whonix-Custom-Workstation ova
- Whonix-Debian-Gateway 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Debian-Gateway 64 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Debian-Workstation 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Debian-Workstation 64 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Custom-Workstation libvirt
- Whonix-Fedora-Gateway 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Fedora-Gateway 64 bit ova
- Whonix-Fedora-Workstation 32 bit ova
- Whonix-Fedora-Workstation 64 bit ova
- Whonix-Fedora-Gateway 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Fedora-Gateway 64 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Fedora-Workstation 32 bit libvirt
- Whonix-Fedora-Workstation 64 bit libvirt
Getting crowded. 18 Images.
How do other distributions solve this?[edit]
How do other distributions deal with 32 bit vs 64 bit, Gnome vs KDE? They provide installer DVDs. Whonix can't do this, since we don't need only getting files installed, but also need the appropriate VM settings / files.
How do other distributions deal with ova vs libvirt? They don't ship any VM images. Leave this to the user. But this is what Whonix does. Shipping pre-configured, ready to use VM images.
What could be attempted is
- 1) getting Whonix's Debian packages merged into Debian and Fedora, which would be a lot work.
- 2) contributing to Debian, so they're not only shipping DVD images, but also VM images.
- 3) making Whonix a blend of Debian and also letting debian's cdimage.debian.org infrastructure build Whonix images.
Future[edit]
Update:
https://forums.whonix.org/t/state-of-offical-64-bit-builds/399/16
For now, the demand for 64 bit builds is too little. No longer shipping 32 bit builds would prevent many users from using Whonix, which already has high system demands.
Maintaining 10 images seems like too much maintenance burden for Patrick.
In meanwhile it is possible to create 64bit builds yourself from source code.
Maybe in future:
- someone implements an automated test suite for Whonix images (see also Tails's automated test suite).
- checked for being verifiable gets automated on a build server among other stuff to ease development.
- a Release Manager joins the project
- a maintainer maintaining 64 bit ova builds joins the project
- a maintainer maintaining 64 bit libvirt builds joins the project
Statistics[edit]
https://labs.riseup.net/code/issues/8183
Forum Discussion[edit]
https://forums.whonix.org/t/state-of-offical-64-bit-builds
Please contribute by helping to answer Whonix questions.
https | (forcing) onion
This is a wiki. Want to improve this page? Help is welcome and volunteer contributions are happily considered! See Conditions for Contributions to Whonix, then Edit! IP addresses are scrubbed, but editing over Tor is recommended. Edits are held for moderation.
Whonix is a licensee of the Open Invention Network. Unless otherwise noted, the content of this page is copyrighted and licensed under the same Libre Software license as Whonix itself. (Why?)